Reading about the passing on of Bunker Roy, took me back to the mid-1970s when I first met him and Aruna at Tilonia. I was then working on a study for ICICI (then a development bank – the Industrial Credit and Investment Corporation of India). Today’s readers might find it strange that a finance institution for large industry would be interested in issues of rural development. But way back in the 1970s, both, the lexicon and grammar of development, were different. The Gandhian philosophy of gram vikas – of holistic development of the villages as self-sufficient harmonious communities – was still a goal that many wanted to achieve. Development of rural India was thought of in terms of reaching the benefits of “modernisation’ and ‘industrialisation’ to the remotest parts of India and to the last person standing; villages were not yet seen as just rural markets. And ICICI still had its development orientation of HT Parekh.
HTP’s objective was to involve industries in rural development projects. Those were
times when industries or businesses, if they contributed to ‘development
projects’, it was more by way of charity or donations. Remember this was long
before terms like corporate philanthropy or corporate social responsibility
became part of the management jargon. He was aware that the corporate sector
would need some incentives to take on such tasks. It was among his many achievements
that he was able to influence the then government to introduce Section 35CC in
the Income-Tax Act. This was a targeted, business-expenditure (100% deduction
for rural development) that operated between 1977 and 1989. Until then, only Section
80G was available as a general (50%) deduction to all taxpayers, including the corporate sector, for monetary
donations made to registered charities and relief funds.
Happy as he was with my studies on the
socio-economic impact of two large industries financed by ICICI– the Gujarat
State Fertilizers Company and Straw Products Ltd (a large paper manufacturing
unit), he asked me to prepare an introductory paper on rural development. The
monograph was published as Perspectives on Rural Development.
Explaining the objectives of the research, this is what he wrote in the Foreword of that booklet. "This introductory paper seeks to bring together information on the
efforts of the Central and State Governments as well as voluntary agencies, financial
institutions, social workers and the corporate sector. To facilitate the
endeavours of those companies and entrepreneurs who wish to take up development
work in rural areas, this paper poses issues which need to be understood while
planning and implementing such programmes”
So the monograph looked at: Programmes of
Central Government; State Governments and Rural Development; Role of Banks in
Rural Development; Voluntary Agencies in Rural Development; Corporate Sector
and Rural Development; Incentives for the Corporate Sector Issues in Rural
Development.
Non-government organisations (NGOs) were
few and far between and were known as social work organisations or voluntary
agencies set up and run by individuals with a vision and passion for development.
It was in connection with this research that Ravi Mathai (of the Jawaja Rural
University) asked me to visit Social Work and Research Centre (Tilonia,
Rajasthan) back in 1976. It was among the handful of voluntary agencies that I
had looked at for the study. These included: Maliwada Human Development Project
(Aurangabad, Maharashtra); Kishore Bharati (Hoshangabad, Madhya Pradesh);
Social Work and Research Centre (Tilonia, Rajasthan) Land Research Institute
(Shedgewadi, Maharashtra) Rural University (Jawaja, Rajasthan) Yusuf Meherally
Centre (Tara, Panvel, Maharashtra).
I would like to quote just one paragraph from that booklet because you can see the germ of the entire Right to Information movement for which Aruna Roy and her team has won recognition.
“One of the major problems that faces
voluntary agencies is lack of resources, both financial and human. Since most
of the activities undertaken by them are in the nature of extension work, they
cannot become self-supporting. They are dependent for funds on Government,
whose procedures may be at times slow and time consuming, on foreign donor
agencies and industries whose grants may not be available on a regular basis. Often
voluntary agencies do not have information about Government resources earmarked
for development of the area in which they operate not about the methods and
procedures for availing of these resources. It is, therefore, not unusual to
come across a situation where on the one hand the voluntary agency complains of
lack of funds and, on the other hand, government provisions lapse for lack of
suitable projects to utilise them.”
Almost four decades later, in 2013, I caught up with Bunker once again when I wrote about “Solar Mamas” for Moneylife magazine. https://www.moneylife.in/article/solar-engineer-grandmothers/32029.html
By then, his work on Barefoot Colleges was being replicated internationally. He had proven that NGOs can be sustainable as well as replicable.



